Litigation
The formal process of resolving a dispute through the court system. Insurance litigation can involve coverage disputes, bad-faith claims, scope-of-work disagreements, or other issues that cannot be resolved through negotiation, appraisal, mediation, or arbitration.
Litigation is the formal court process for resolving a dispute through a judge or jury. In insurance, it is the step beyond negotiation, appraisal, mediation, and arbitration — the backstop when other processes fail or are bypassed.
Why Claims Go to Court
Claims reach litigation when disputes remain after other processes, when the parties cannot agree to a voluntary process, or when the nature of the dispute requires a judicial ruling. Common litigation paths include coverage denials the policyholder disputes, bad-faith allegations against the carrier, scope-of-work disputes that exceed appraisal jurisdiction, and third-party liability disputes requiring court adjudication.
The Process at a High Level
A case begins with the complaint and answer. Discovery follows, where both sides exchange documents, take depositions, and develop evidence. Motions narrow the issues. Most cases settle during or after discovery. A small percentage go to trial, where a judge or jury decides the outcome. Appeals can follow, extending the timeline further. From filing to final resolution can take a year or several years.
Costs and Considerations
Litigation is expensive. Attorney fees, expert witnesses, court costs, and time add up on both sides. Many jurisdictions allow prevailing policyholders to recover attorney fees in bad-faith cases, which changes the economic calculus. Policyholders considering litigation typically consult with insurance coverage attorneys who can evaluate the strength of the case, the likely cost, and alternative paths before filing suit.
Frequently asked questions
Typically after other resolution options have failed or been bypassed. If appraisal, mediation, and negotiation have not produced resolution, or if a policy does not require an alternative process, the policyholder or carrier may file suit. Bad-faith claims, involving alleged improper claim handling, often proceed directly through litigation.
From filing to judgment can take a year or more, depending on the court's backlog and the complexity of the case. Many cases settle before trial, often during mediation or after discovery reveals the strength of each side's position. A small fraction proceed all the way to verdict and appeal.
Standard recovery includes the policy benefits owed. Bad-faith claims in many states allow additional damages including attorney fees, consequential damages, and in some jurisdictions punitive damages for egregious conduct. Specifics depend heavily on state law.
No credit card required