Matching Provision
A policy provision or state regulation that requires the insurance carrier to pay for replacement of undamaged materials when the damaged materials cannot be reasonably matched in color, style, or appearance after a partial loss.
What Is a Matching Provision
A matching provision is a policy clause or state regulation that obligates the insurance carrier to pay for replacement of undamaged materials when the materials damaged by a covered loss cannot be reasonably matched in color, texture, pattern, or appearance with available replacement products, ensuring the repaired property does not have a visibly inconsistent appearance. The provision applies most commonly to roofing, siding, and interior finishes where partial replacement creates a visible mismatch.
When Matching Applies
Matching becomes an issue when the original material has been discontinued, the color has been retired by the manufacturer, or the existing material has weathered to a shade that no new product can match. On roofs, this commonly occurs with asphalt shingle colors that were popular 10 to 15 years ago but are no longer in production. If three slopes need replacement and the fourth slope has undamaged shingles of a discontinued color, the matching provision may require replacing the fourth slope as well to maintain a uniform appearance.
Matching and Insurance Claims
Matching disputes are among the most common supplement battles in residential insurance restoration. To support a matching supplement, document the existing product with photographs and manufacturer identification, confirm in writing that the product or color is unavailable, and photograph any available alternatives next to the existing material to demonstrate the mismatch. Some states have specific matching regulations that require carriers to match to a reasonable standard. Others leave it to policy language. Know your state's position on matching before filing the supplement.
Frequently asked questions
A matching provision requires the carrier to pay for replacing undamaged materials adjacent to the damaged area when the damaged materials cannot be matched in color, style, or appearance. If a discontinued shingle product cannot be matched on a repaired slope, the matching provision may require the carrier to pay for replacing the entire slope or the entire roof to maintain uniform appearance.
Document the existing product name, manufacturer, and color. Contact the manufacturer or distributor to confirm the product is discontinued or the specific color is unavailable. Photograph the existing material next to any available replacement options to show the visible mismatch. Obtain a written statement from the manufacturer or supplier confirming the product is not available.
No credit card required