Best Roofing Shingles
A comparison of the top shingle brands and product types for residential roofing, covering asphalt architectural, premium designer, and impact-resistant lines from the major manufacturers.
Specifications
| Top Manufacturers | GAF, Owens Corning, CertainTeed, Atlas, TAMKO, IKO |
| Best-Selling Line (U.S.) | GAF Timberline HDZ (architectural, 130 mph wind warranty) |
| Premium Tier | CertainTeed Grand Manor, GAF Grand Sequoia, Owens Corning Berkshire |
| Impact-Resistant | Class 4 rated shingles (UL 2218 tested) from all major brands |
Common issues
- Selecting shingles based on appearance alone without considering wind and impact ratings for the region
- Confusing manufacturer warranty length with realistic product lifespan
- Not verifying that the installer is certified by the shingle manufacturer, which can void enhanced warranty coverage
Insurance relevance
Shingle selection directly affects insurance outcomes. Many insurers offer premium discounts for Class 4 impact-resistant shingles, often 5 to 28 percent depending on the state. When a claim results in a full roof replacement, the replacement shingle must match the quality and type of the original or meet current code, whichever is higher. If the original shingle has been discontinued, matching profiles and warranties from the same or comparable manufacturer becomes a supplement item.
How to Compare Roofing Shingles
Choosing the best roofing shingle requires evaluating several factors beyond appearance: wind rating, impact resistance, warranty structure, weight per square, manufacturer reputation, and installer certification programs. The three dominant manufacturers in the U.S. market are GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed, with Atlas, TAMKO, and IKO holding significant regional market share. Each offers product lines at three general tiers: economy (3-tab), mid-range (standard architectural), and premium (designer or luxury). Within each tier, the key differentiators are wind warranty, impact resistance class, algae resistance, and color selection. Performance ratings from independent testing (UL 2218 for impact, ASTM D3161 and D7158 for wind) provide objective comparison points beyond marketing claims.
Top Shingle Lines by Manufacturer
GAF Timberline HDZ is the best-selling residential shingle in the United States. It carries a 130 mph wind warranty backed by the StainGuard Plus algae protection limited warranty. GAF also offers the Timberline AS II, which adds Class 4 impact resistance. Owens Corning Duration is the brand's flagship architectural line, featuring their SureNail Technology strip for enhanced wind resistance. CertainTeed Landmark is the primary mid-range competitor, with the Landmark Pro adding a weathered wood appearance and StreakFighter algae resistance. Atlas StormMaster Slate and StormMaster Shake are designed specifically for impact resistance, using the Scotchgard Protector coating from 3M. Each manufacturer also offers premium designer lines that replicate slate or cedar shake aesthetics at a higher price point and heavier weight per square.
Impact Resistance and Wind Ratings
Impact-resistant shingles are tested under UL 2218, which drops a 2-inch steel ball from 20 feet onto the shingle surface. Class 4 is the highest rating, meaning the shingle shows no fracture after two impacts on the same spot. Shingles that achieve Class 4 are available from all major manufacturers and typically qualify for insurance premium discounts. Wind ratings are tested under ASTM D3161 (Fan-Induced Method) and ASTM D7158 (Uplift Resistance). The highest designation under D7158 is Class H, which corresponds to a 150 mph uplift resistance. GAF Timberline HDZ carries a 130 mph limited wind warranty. When comparing wind ratings, distinguish between the tested uplift resistance and the manufacturer's limited warranty speed, as these are not always the same number.
Choosing the Right Shingle for Insurance Performance
For homeowners in hail-prone states like Texas, Colorado, Minnesota, and Kansas, a Class 4 impact-resistant shingle is often the best value choice because of the insurance premium discount it triggers. Many states mandate that insurers offer a discount for Class 4 roofs, typically ranging from 5 to 28 percent of the premium. Over a 30-year roof life, this discount can offset or exceed the upgrade cost. For high-wind coastal areas, selecting a shingle with a 130 mph or higher wind warranty and ensuring proper nail placement (6 nails per shingle in the correct nailing zone) is more important than the specific brand. In any region, choosing a manufacturer whose contractor certification program is supported by local installers ensures access to enhanced warranties that cover both materials and workmanship, rather than materials only.
Frequently asked questions
GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed are the three most widely recommended shingle manufacturers in North America. GAF holds the largest market share, with the Timberline HDZ being the best-selling residential shingle in the United States. Owens Corning Duration and CertainTeed Landmark are the primary competitors in the mid-range architectural category. The best brand for a specific project depends on regional availability, contractor certification, warranty terms, and performance requirements for the local climate.
Premium shingles offer thicker construction, longer warranties, more realistic dimensional profiles, and often better wind and impact ratings. For homes in hail-prone or high-wind regions, upgrading to a Class 4 impact-resistant shingle can pay for itself through insurance premium reductions. For homes in mild climates with no severe weather exposure, a standard architectural shingle provides strong performance at a lower cost per square.
Yes. When a roof is replaced under an insurance claim, the replacement shingle should match the type and quality of the original. If the original was a premium architectural shingle, the replacement should be comparable. Brand-specific pricing differences are reflected in Xactimate material costs. Additionally, installing a manufacturer-certified contractor can activate enhanced warranty coverage, which some insurers factor into policy terms.
Convert your PDF to ESX
Upload a PDF estimate. CapOut processes it and sends it directly to your Xactimate account.
Get started free
No credit card required